Coursya originals · Free PDF ebook

Whose Advice Should You Follow When Good People Disagree?

Compare conflicting recommendations fairly and choose a next step you can explain in your own words. An illustrated English PDF with 16 content pages and practical worksheets.

Decision-Making & Delegation

Two sensible people can give opposite advice because they assume different goals, time horizons or tolerances for risk. Your first task is to understand their reasoning. Then decide which parts fit your situation and where the remaining uncertainty belongs.

Compare conflicting recommendations fairly and choose a next step you can explain in your own words.

Who this ebook is for

Readers receiving conflicting recommendations from trusted people. The guide uses everyday situations, practical wording and short exercises that you can adapt to your own circumstances.

What you will learn

  • Write the decision in your own terms. Before collecting more advice, describe the actual choice, deadline, people affected and constraints. An adviser may answer the question they wish you had asked.
  • Ask for the assumptions behind the recommendation. Invite each adviser to explain when their advice works and when it would fail. Pay attention to the outcome they value and the resources they assume you have.
  • Match expertise to the question. Someone can know your preferences well while knowing little about a specialist matter. Another person may know the field well but not your household constraints.
  • Look for the point of agreement. Different advice may share a low-risk next step. Ask what both people would want you to find out before committing.
  • Own the final trade-off. Advice can inform a decision but cannot transfer its consequences to the adviser. State the benefit you want, the cost you accept and the fact that could change your view.

Decide whether to take a course now

A mentor says enroll immediately; a friend says wait. The mentor sees a career opening and the friend knows your current workload.

Write down the real course dates, price, participation requirements and the decision deadline.

Ask the mentor which opportunity depends on starting now. Ask the friend which commitments would be squeezed and whether any can move.

Competing advice has become a set of answerable questions and a personal choice.

Put the guide into practice

Choose one situation you expect to face soon. Work through the relevant example, then use the worksheet to write a response or plan you can realistically follow. The prompts include:

  • The decision in my words
  • Advice, expertise and assumptions
  • The fact or value driving disagreement
  • My chosen trade-off and next check

About the PDF download

The English-language PDF has 19 pages: 16 content pages, a cover and two advertisement pages. It includes 12 fillable worksheet fields. Use a PDF reader that supports forms to type and save your responses, or print the pages and write by hand.

A templates advertisement follows content page 5, and a Coursera Plus advertisement follows content page 15. Each advertisement image is fully clickable. These are promotional links and Coursya may earn a commission from a purchase. A purchase is optional.

Frequently asked questions

Who is this ebook for?

Readers receiving conflicting recommendations from trusted people. Compare conflicting recommendations fairly and choose a next step you can explain in your own words.

How can I use the worksheets?

The PDF includes 12 fillable fields for your own notes and decisions. Open it in a reader that supports PDF forms, save a copy after entering your responses and reopen that copy to check your work. The worksheets can also be printed.

What is included in the free download?

One complete English-language PDF with 16 content pages, illustrated explanations, examples and practice activities. The 19-page file also includes its cover and two linked advertisements. You can read and use the guide without buying anything.

Share this article