Business Model Comparison
Project workbook · Path 61

Compare a product and a service model, expose their assumptions and design a small evidence-gathering experiment.

The case

A fictional repair club considers selling a printed maintenance kit or providing a monthly workshop. Neither option has been tested with customers. The figures below are hypotheses for one month, not forecasts or investment recommendations.

ModelUnitsPriceVariable cost per unitFixed cost
Kit40208300
Workshop203510400
STAGE 1

Identify the customer job

Start with the situation a customer wants to improve. A proposed solution is not the same as an observed need. Keep the customer, beneficiary and payer separate when they differ. In this case no interview has happened, so write hypotheses rather than invented customer quotations.

Your task

Write two customer situations and label every unverified claim.

Required output

Customer hypothesis sheet

Record your result and evidence here or in a separate file.

Review gate

The sheet contains no fictional quotation presented as research.

If the gate is not met

Rewrite assumed preferences as questions to investigate.

STAGE 2

Compare delivery models

Compare what each model delivers, the activities required and the relationship after purchase. A product model may still require service and a service model may use products. Avoid choosing a label first and forcing the case into it. The comparison should help explain operating differences.

Your task

Map the kit and workshop against delivery, support, resources and payment.

Required output

Two-model comparison

Record your result and evidence here or in a separate file.

Review gate

Each model has a distinct delivery process and a named payer.

If the gate is not met

Describe actual activities instead of repeating model labels.

STAGE 3

Connect the financial assumptions

Contribution is revenue minus variable cost; it must still cover fixed costs. Compare the models at the supplied volume and test a lower volume. This simple calculation excludes tax, financing and many real-world costs. Its purpose is to reveal which assumptions matter, not to predict a business outcome.

Your task

Calculate monthly contribution and surplus, then reduce each volume by 25%.

Required output

Scenario calculation

Record your result and evidence here or in a separate file.

Review gate

Base surpluses are 180 and 100; reduced-volume surpluses are 60 and -25.

If the gate is not met

Keep unit costs separate from monthly fixed costs.

STAGE 4

Design a discriminating experiment

A useful experiment can change a decision. Define the uncertainty, the observation needed and the stopping rule before collecting evidence. Avoid treating polite interest as a purchase. A no-cost interview or mock offer can test understanding, while actual willingness to pay would require a carefully designed later test.

Your task

Plan five voluntary interviews with neutral questions and a decision rule. Do not contact anyone for this exercise.

Required output

Experiment protocol

Record your result and evidence here or in a separate file.

Review gate

The protocol says what result would weaken each model.

If the gate is not met

Replace questions that praise your idea with questions about recent behavior.

STAGE 5

Write a conditional recommendation

A recommendation should distinguish known arithmetic from unknown demand. State what you would test first and why, and identify conditions under which the other model becomes preferable. Keep a versioned assumption register so new evidence can change the model without hiding the earlier reasoning.

Your task

Write a one-page comparison and prioritize the three riskiest assumptions.

Required output

Decision memo and assumption register

Record your result and evidence here or in a separate file.

Review gate

The recommendation is conditional and includes an explicit next evidence step.

If the gate is not met

Remove certainty words unsupported by the case.

Final project

Deliver the customer hypotheses, two-model map, base and downside calculations, interview protocol and conditional memo. Add a third scenario with a higher support cost and explain how the recommendation changes.

Critical condition

All demand and cost assumptions are labeled; no hypothetical revenue is presented as earned.

CriterionPointsEvidence
Evidence and correctness30Calculations, source use and results match the supplied case; limitations are honest.
Required artifacts30All five stage outputs and the capstone handoff are present and inspectable.
Reasoning and decisions20Choices, assumptions, alternatives and the case-specific critical condition are explained.
Reproducibility10A reviewer can follow the stated steps and distinguish expected from observed results.
Clear communication10Labels, units, structure and evidence references make the work easy to review.

Score at least 80/100, supply every required artifact, and satisfy the path-specific critical condition. Rework missing evidence before marking complete.

Worked reference

The kit generates 40 × (20 − 8) − 300 = 180. The workshop generates 20 × (35 − 10) − 400 = 100. At 75% of those volumes, the results are 60 and −25. The kit looks stronger under these assumptions; the arithmetic does not establish demand, quality or long-term viability.

Boundaries

This is a fictional model-design exercise, not financial advice or validation of a real venture.